UPDATE 12/05/2024: Rocket Mortgage just sued HUD in a new lawsuit 24-cv-03368. They claim they are not responsible for third party AMCs and appraisers. The DOJ provided the borrower named of Francesca Cheroutes. Rocket gave Francesca Cheroutes two chances to do a Reconsideration Of Value ROV or appraisal appeal. She declined. The address provided by DOJ is 749-751 Ash Street, Denver, Colorado. Owner lives in one unit and rents out the other.
Rocket Mortgage's main argument is that Rocket did not have a duty to "correct" the appraisal. Appraisers, AMCs are independent third parties. The government is the one that mandated that appraisers, appraisals be independent. They don't want lenders pressuring appraisers. Legally Rocket is not allowed to "correct" an appraisal. They are not allowed to even try to influence an appraiser, appraisal per the law. They further argue that they told borrower they could send in an ROV to the AMC which gives it to the appraiser but borrower refused. Failure to mitigate a claim. Lender can't send in the ROV. I agree with Rocket Mortgage.
*Everything in this article is based on public records such a building records, public MLS/rent listings, the public filed lawsuit and the public DOJ report.
Per DOJ, borrower and Zillow subject is two units, six beds, four baths, 3,550 sf and each unit is two floors. That's almost double the actual finished GLA and bed/bath count. The units are 2 beds, 1 bath 1,500 or so sf total with full basements which are not 100% finished. There is one floor and a basement level. Credit was given for the basement. Duplex comps with similar basements used. This is an area where properties would all have full basements. Zillow/Trulia value today December 2024 after three years of appreciation $826,000 based on 6+4 3,500 sf. Then I doubt it was worth $860,000 in January 20, 2020. RedFn says $797,000 with same wrong bed/bath. I obviously put no weight in Zillow, RedFn values. Clearly the borrower wanted the incorrect Zillow bed/bath count and value. Borrower claims she had a no inspection "valuation" March 2022 for $885,000. Sounds like an AVM or free broker CMA BPO for listing which would be higher than market value.
Multifamily properties are different than SFR. They generally include GBA Gross Building Area. That can include other areas if it's 100% finished. The most important thing is to compare apples to apples. In this area most duplexes, SFRs have full basements. Some are finished, some have "legal" beds/baths and some don't. The appraiser used similar comps and included basement adjustments.
I did not do the original appraisal. I live in an area where basements and especially full basements are very uncommon in Los Angeles, California. They are never in GBA of 2-4 units. They are generally never 100% finished. At most they are crawl spaces or small utility basements. We have/had a high water table and basements would flood which is why we don't have them. Most of them have no windows or legal exits from all rooms. You need a legal sized window exit from bedrooms to legally be a bedroom. You don't want to get trapped in there in a flood or fire.
It turns out the black female attorney was happy with a few previous refinances of the property. They still have their mortgage with Rocket including the servicing. They didn't go get another loan with a new lender. This appears to be another false claim of bias and discrimination. This woman filed complaints in a few places. Read the documents and come to your own conclusion.
Per DOJ January 2021 $640,000 appraisal value. Appraisal from previous year was allegedly $860,000. It appears the previous value was perhaps too high. Francesca lied to the DOJ about requesting a reconsideration of value. She didn't request one. She should have requested a ROV. Then the issue of GLA, GBA could have been clarified. Borrower stated she merely complained about racial discrimination and demanded a higher value. It would have taken her half an hour to submit a ROV. She should have done that. Failure to mitigate damages, if there were any damages. We also don't know if her credit score, debt ratio, income levels, job history, judgments, liens, payment history ... affected her credit rating. There are many reasons to be denied a loan. The appraisal value is just one of them. If you have great income, great credit, little debt, long time job history ... a lower appraisal value wouldn't matter as much especially as this is owner occupied.
Here is the property per Zillow with size of 3 bed, 2 bath1,550 sf. That value is $557,000 today. It shows only one unit. The actual units are about 2 bed, 1 bath 700-800 sf GLA each with additional basement. One place even lists this as four units. I think they took the data from a rental offering of one unit. See how inaccurate Zillow can be.
https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/749-N-Ash-St-Denver-CO-80220/2067840283_zpid/?
Zillow value adding basement. It shows two units adding basements to first floor. Basement was given credit in the appraisal. There were no beds, baths in the basement per original appraisal. It's just laundry, exposed water heater, exposed furnace, electrical outlet on outside of wall, pipes on outside of ceiling. Maybe the owner has since updated the basement. It's listed as full basement but not 100% finished.
https://www.zillow.com/homedetails/749-751-Ash-St-Denver-CO-80220/2054732090_zpid/
Property data https://www.denvergov.org/property/realproperty/summary/0606314009000/
One unit was offered for rent for $3,000 October 2024. Looks like it had upgrades in 2022. It was previously listed for $3,500 then $3,400 then $3,200. It states recent renovations. https://www.trulia.com/home/749-n-ash-st-denver-co-80220-2067840283
One unit was offered for rent for $2,800 November 2021. You can see the basement level. Photo from that listing. Half size windows so a lot less light. Legal basement egress windows must be at least 24 inches tall and 20 inches wide. I can't tell if that is 24 inches but maybe it isn't. The window must be minimum 5.7 sf area and no more than 44" off the floor. Again, it may not be big enough. As I look at interior, exterior photos I don't know if the windows meet those minimums. People need to be able to escape in a fire or flood. I don't see the current basement bedroom windows. These pics are recent after a remodel with new carpet, paint... I see exposed plumbing, electrical so not 100% finished. I see some wonkiness in an interior wall under the window which looks like water damage. Again, I'm not the appraiser and haven't seen the property.
https://www.zumperrentals.com/apartments-for-rent/12060314p/3-bedroom-hale-denver-co?gallery=#media-447399980
Here is the racial bias accusation. She had a Black Lives Matter BLM sign on the property and appraiser walked by it. Sounds like the woman just wanted the lender to give her a higher value so she could refinance her loan again. She may have tried to go to another lender with another appraisal and that appraisal was probably also low so she didn't refinance. Perhaps she was able to pressure the previous appraiser. It sounds like she was trying to pressure the appraiser in this case.
Link to the complaint.
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1YY7L-lJ-8nQBsBEJA9H7U-K0Y1i3deWP/view?usp=sharing
Below is the court docket for the current case.
U.S. District Court - District of Colorado
District of Colorado (Denver)
CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 1:24-cv-03368-REB
Rocket Mortgage, LLC v. United States Department of Housing and Urban Development
Assigned to: Judge Robert E. Blackburn
Cause: 05:0706 - Judicial Review of Agency Action
Date Filed: 12/04/2024
Jury Demand: None
Nature of Suit: 899 APA Review/Appeal
Jurisdiction: U.S. Government Defendant
Plaintiff
Rocket Mortgage, LLC represented by Angelica Rankins
Goodwin Procter LLP
1900 N Street NW
Washington, DC 20036
202-346-4000
Email:
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Brooks R. Brown
Goodwin Procter LLP
100 Northern Avenue
Boston, MA 02210
617-570-1000
Email:
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Keith Eric Levenberg
Goodwin Procter LLP
1900 N Street NW
Washington, DC 20036
202-346-4000
Email:
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
Jeffrey Brian Morganroth
Morganroth & Morganroth, PLLC
344 North Old Woodward Avenue
Suite 200
Birmingham, MI 48009
248-864-4000
Fax: 248-864-4001
Email:
ATTORNEY TO BE NOTICED
V.
Defendant
United States Department of Housing and Urban Development
Date Filed # Docket Text
12/04/2024 1 COMPLAINT against United States Department of Housing and Urban Development (Filing fee $ 405,Receipt Number BCODC-10018454)Attorney Jeffrey Brian Morganroth added to party Rocket Mortgage, LLC(pty:pla), filed by Rocket Mortgage, LLC. (Attachments: # 1 Civil Cover Sheet, # 2 Summons, # 3 Summons, # 4 Summons)(Morganroth, Jeffrey) (Entered: 12/04/2024)
12/04/2024 2 CORPORATE DISCLOSURE STATEMENT identifying Corporate Parent Rocket Companies, Inc., Corporate Parent Rocket, LLC for Rocket Mortgage, LLC. (Morganroth, Jeffrey) (Entered: 12/04/2024)
12/04/2024 3 NOTICE of Related Cases by Plaintiff Rocket Mortgage, LLC (Morganroth, Jeffrey) (Entered: 12/04/2024)
12/04/2024 4 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Brooks R. Brown on behalf of Rocket Mortgage, LLCAttorney Brooks R. Brown added to party Rocket Mortgage, LLC(pty:pla) (Brown, Brooks) (Entered: 12/04/2024)
12/04/2024 5 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Keith Eric Levenberg on behalf of Rocket Mortgage, LLCAttorney Keith Eric Levenberg added to party Rocket Mortgage, LLC(pty:pla) (Levenberg, Keith) (Entered: 12/04/2024)
12/04/2024 6 NOTICE of Entry of Appearance by Angelica Rankins on behalf of Rocket Mortgage, LLCAttorney Angelica Rankins added to party Rocket Mortgage, LLC(pty:pla) (Rankins, Angelica) (Entered: 12/04/2024)
12/05/2024 7 Case assigned to Judge Robert E. Blackburn. Text Only Entry. (agryan) (Entered: 12/05/2024)
12/05/2024 8 SUMMONS issued by Clerk. (Attachments: # 1 Summons, # 2 Summons, # 3 Magistrate Judge Consent Form) (agryan) (Entered: 12/05/2024)
DOJ case which lists name of owner and address. We now have address, values and dates.
https://www.justice.gov/opa/media/1374081/dl?inline
Below is heading of DOJ v Rocket case 24-cv-02915 Denver, Colorado. Francesca is listed as a Plaintiff intervenor with attorney andy@newman-mcnulty.com So far the case was reassigned a few times then Rocket filed the Motion to Dismiss 12/04/2024. Below is Francesca's complaint. Francesca publicly shared her identity and home address. She shares misinformation and articles about the false narrative of the alleged "racist white appraiser" in her complaint. October 2024 USA Today, NY Times mentioned her in their articles about the case. Here is one article with a photo of Francesca. She shared this information publicly so she is legally liable for defamation. There is no litigation privilege when you share false information publicly. This is why the Maryland appraiser sued the property owners. https://www.nytimes.com/2024/12/06/realestate/rocket-mortgage-lawsuit-appraisals.html
https://drive.google.com/file/d/1REwJ4TECl1g_1JzcVytpBAMK3i6k2hTw/view?usp=sharing
U.S. District Court - District of Colorado
District of Colorado (Denver)
CIVIL DOCKET FOR CASE #: 1:24-cv-02915-GPG-TPO
USA v. Rocket Mortgage, LLC et al
Assigned to: District Judge Gordon P Gallagher
Referred to: Magistrate Judge Timothy P O'Hara
Cause: 42:3612 - Civil Rights in Housing -- Enforcement by Secretary
Date Filed: 10/21/2024
Jury Demand: Plaintiff
Nature of Suit: 440 Civil Rights: Other
Jurisdiction: U.S. Government Plaintiff
Plaintiff
As I read the DOJ complaint the borrower believed maintenance items were improvements. They also did the craziest "appraisal" math using cost per bedroom of final value to give value to basement areas. They used average price per square foot of Denver area, average appreciation...many things an appraiser would not use. They mention the 10, 15, 25% guideline adjustments. Those are not mandatory. The issue was she could not refi her apx $550K loan with a value under $860K. Borrower does mention GLA, GBA issue. She complained about racial discrimination but did not file a ROV even when offered twice. She should have filed a ROV to deal with her issues.
ORIGINAL 07/16/2024: "HUD Charges Appraiser, Appraisal Management Company, and Lender with Race Discrimination WASHINGTON - The U.S. Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) announced today that it has charged multiple entities with housing discrimination for issuing a biased appraisal and then denying a refinance loan application in Denver, Colorado. HUD’s Charge against the appraiser, M* M*; appraisal company, M* Appraisal Group; appraisal management company, Solidifi U.S. Inc.; and lender, Rocket Mortgage, LLC, alleges that the appraiser issued a discriminatory appraisal that undervalued a Black homeowner’s property on the basis of her race. The Charge further alleges that, when the homeowner complained to Rocket Mortgage, Rocket Mortgage would only proceed with her refinance loan application based on the appraised value that she alleged was discriminatory."
This is the first complaint HUD has investigated in years. The lack of finished investigations is probably one reason why Marcia Fudge was shown the door. As usual there is no property address or borrower/owner name so we can't ascertain if the appraisal values were accurate or not. Of course there are no appraisals just values and dates. When we know the name or address we appraisers have been able to tell if the appraisal values were accurate or not. This is intentional so the public will never know and we must just believe the HUD press release.
This case sounds a lot like the Oakland case. Sounds like an area going through revitalization. Some homes are fully renovated and some are not. Values vary greatly based on specific location and condition per the data we have. HUD again brings up race of area. Appraisers never look at census records or race data. Race of area is from census records. Census has to do with who lives there and not who owns the property. There is the race income wealth correlation which means areas with more white occupants are probably worth more because they are probably fully renovated and in slightly better locations. This is an assumption based on research which shows white areas are worth more than black or Latino areas. I really wish they'd include the address so we wouldn't have to just guess and speculate. We will probably never know but based on my experience the higher ones are generally wrong. Lower ones are generally correct.
I predict the lender, AMC will settle for a slap on the wrist without admitting or denying guilt. They'll release a press release saying that have always been and always will be committed to fair housing. The appraiser will sadly settle without paying money because he can't afford to litigate. He will be forced to watch the mockumentary Lowballed strapped to a chair and attend a bias class by a private fair housing organization who was a friend of ex HUD chief Marcia Fudge. HUD will release news of the settlement stating they are helping POC obtain fair housing and loans. No one will ever know which appraisals were correct and which were not. No problems are solved. No one is helped. Things haven't changed. The PAVE task force was just a lot of talk and more administrative paperwork for lenders and appraisers.
https://www.hud.gov/press/press_releases_media_advisories/HUD_No_24_181
The charge
https://www.hud.gov/sites/dfiles/FHEO/documents/Charge_08-21-3530-8.pdf
Mary Cummins of Cummins Real Estate is a certified residential licensed appraiser in Los Angeles, California. Mary Cummins is licensed by the California Bureau of Real Estate appraisers and has over 35 years of experience.
- Mary Cummins LinkedIn
- Mary Cummins Meet up
- Cummins Real Estate on Facebook
- Mary Cummins Real Estate blog
- Cummins Real Estate on Google maps
- Mary Cummins of Animal Advocates
- Mary Cummins biography resume short
- Mary Cummins Real Estate Services
- Animal Advocates fan page at Facebook.com
- Mary Cummins
- Mary Cummins Animal Advocates on Flickr photos
- Mary Cummins Animal Advocates on Twitter.com
- Mary Cummins on MySpace.com
- Mary Cummins on YouTube.com videos
- Mary Cummins of Animal Advocates on Classmates
- Mary Cummins on VK
Mary Cummins, Mary K. Cummins, Mary Katherine Cummins, Mary, Cummins, #marycummins #animaladvocates #losangeles #california #wildlife #wildliferehabilitation #wildliferehabilitator #realestate #realestateappraiser #realestateappraisal #lawsuit real estate, appraiser, appraisal, instructor, teacher, Los Angeles, Santa Monica, Beverly Hills, Pasadena, Brentwood, Bel Air, California, licensed, permitted, certified, single family, condo, condominium, pud, hud, fannie mae, freddie mac, fha, uspap, certified, residential, certified resident, apartment building, multi-family, commercial, industrial, expert witness, civil, criminal, orea, dre, brea insurance, bonded, experienced, bilingual, spanish, english, form, 1004, 2055, 1073, land, raw, acreage, vacant, insurance, cost, income approach, market analysis, comparative, theory, appraisal theory, cost approach, sales, matched pairs, plot, plat, map, diagram, photo, photographs, photography, rear, front, street, subject, comparable, sold, listed, active, pending, expired, cancelled, listing, mls, multiple listing service, claw, themls, historical appraisal, facebook, linkedin
DISCLAIMER: https://mary--cummins.blogspot.com/p/disclaimer-privacy-policy-for-blogs-by.html
